'Combinational' computer keyboard layout

31 December 2017
Canonical namecombinational.en.ansi
LanguageEnglish
Form factorSlab : ANSI
'Author'Nelson (1920)
Author data may not be correct, we're working on it.
Keys horizontally staggeredYes
Letters on thumb0
Uses AltGr for standard charactersNo
Moves non-character keys (ANSI/ISO)No
Changes 'shift' pairsNo
Changes top row (ANSI/ISO)No
Uppercase on different keyNo

Click image for larger view

combinational.en.ansi


Download the Keyboard Layout Analyzer .json file.

Rankings

MetricRankRelative %
KLA original English prose28966.82
KLA original Programming34249.41
Den 1 English prose32456.92
Den 1 Programming35044.36
Homekeys words2670.78
Homeblock words954.89
Angle mod Homeblock words934.53
Easyblock words436.84
One-handed words1938.85
Efficiency31664.38
Homekeys bigrams27048.91
Homekeys trigrams11251.71
Homekeys quadgrams10334.70
Homekeys common words16649.21
Samefinger bigrams281 1.87
Overall ranking24741.05

Finger based metrics

Finger based metrics, as determined with Keyboard Layout Analyzer, using Patrick's original scoring model, and Den's first revised version.

We show the ranking Overall, for the broad Form Factor, and against other similar layouts (Peers), for English prose, assorted Programming, and Average of the two.

'Peers' means compared to other layouts with same characterics, e.g. ANSI/ISO vs Ergo, and matching 'Has letters on thumb', 'Uses AltGr for standard characters', 'Moves non-character keys (ANSI/ISO)', 'Changes shift pairs', 'Changes top row (ANSI/ISO)', and 'Uppercase on different key', as listed above.

 OverallOverallOverall ANSI/ISOANSI/ISOANSI/ISO PeersPeersPeers
Scoring modelEnglish proseProgrammingCombined English proseProgrammingCombined English proseProgrammingCombined
KLA original289 / 360342 / 360306 / 360184 / 252234 / 252201 / 25268 / 114101 / 11479 / 114
Den 1324 / 360350 / 360334 / 360218 / 252242 / 252226 / 25290 / 114106 / 11497 / 114

English Word-based analysis

Home Keys Analysis

The Home Keys for this layout are shown with red dots in the image above, giving the following letters:

abehrstw

Home key bigrams, trigrams, quadgrams and common words

Scores are based on which fingers are used for the top 20 bigrams, trigrams and quadgrams, and top 30 common words, with the scores weighted by strength of finger used, and frequency of occurance of the text.

MetricRankWeighted scoreComponents handled and not handled
Bigrams27044.1 / 90.17th he er re at ha es in an nd on en ou ed to or it is hi ng
Trigrams11220.52 / 39.68the her hat tha ere ter was and ing his for ent ion you ith ver all wit thi tio
Quadgrams1035.51 / 15.88that ther here were with tion ould ight have hich whic this thin they atio ever from ough hing ment
Common words16641.56 / 84.45the a that was he as at be are has of and to in is for on with it his by from this I but have an not they or
Home Key lettersEnglish words typeableLongest wordExample
whtsearb136211hartebeests

Word count
Word length

Easyblock Analysis

The typical Easyblock Keys for this layout form factor are shown here:
Easyblock lettersEnglish words typeableLongest wordExample
gGdDoOuUhHtTsSeEaArRlLmM1298516thermoregulators

Word count
Word length

Homeblock Analysis

The typical Homeblock Keys for this layout form factor are shown here:
Homeblock lettersEnglish words typeableLongest wordExample
gGdDnNiIoOuUhHtTsSeEaArRcCpPlLmMyY14999632dichlorodiphenyltrichloroethanes

Word count
Word length

Angle Mod Homeblock Analysis

The typical Angle Mod Homeblock Keys for this layout form factor are shown here:
Angle mod Homeblock lettersEnglish words typeableLongest wordExample
gGdDnNiIoOuUhHtTsSeEaArRxXcCpPmMyY9436624microspectrophotometries

Word count
Word length

One-handed words Analysis

This looks at how many words can be typed with only left or right hand. We want these numbers to be low.
This metric was done "strictly" ... shifted or AltGr letters were only included if Shift or AltGr was on the same hand.
Note: we exclude the Dvorak one-handed layouts comparison, since clearly by design they can type every possible word with one hand.
Left hand lettersLeft wordsLongest left wordLeft exampleRight hand lettersRight wordsLongest right wordRight exampleTotal
zZgGdDnNvVwWhHtTsSkKxXcCpPlL1717tsktsks iIoOuUfFqQeEaArRbBjJmMyY161512armourbearer 1786

Left handRight hand
Word count
Word lengthWord length

SameFinger Bigrams

This is a weighted analysis of same-finger usage.

The probability that a letter will follow another given letter is used to evaluate layouts by which letters pairs are on the same fingers. We multiply this figure by the percentage frequency of the first letter, in English.
We add the probabilities in both directions, for example "er" and "re".

There are some exceptions: We only look at lower case, and if the second letter is on the same key as the first, we ignore that pair.

The idea is to see how much a finger has to fly around, and if the two letters are on the same key (as in the split-case layouts) then it doesn't have to fly between them.

The metric does not measure how far the finger has to fly, just that it has to. I'll look at adding distance, row jumps, inward rolls, outward rolls, to this metric if possible.

FingerLettersScore
Left pinky'zvwkx' 0.5587
Left ring'ghc' 76.3793
Left middle'dtp' 7.5111
Left index'nsl' 53.8304
Left thumb'⍽' 0
Right thumb'' 0
Right index'iem' 184.1453
Right middle'oay' 55.9475
Right ring'ur' 48.4515
Right pinky'fqbj' 1.298
Both thumbs'' 0
Total 428.12

Word metric comparisons

MetricLowestLowest scorecombinational.en.ansi scoreHighestHighest score
Home keysabcdef.en.ansi31362
essie-2.en.matrix174012
Easyblockqwerty-rehomed.en.ansi10012985
essie-3-wip.en.ergolinear189738
Homeblockqwerty-typewriter.en.ansi1562149996
essie-3-wip.en.ergolinear273265
Angle mod Homeblockalphametric.en.ansi135494366
essie-3-wip.en.ergolinear273265
Left hand wordsqgmlwy.en.ergolinear34171
tnwmlc.en.ansi22157
Right hand wordsessie-3.en.ergolinear261615
reverse-qwerty.en.ansi14771
Total single handedessie-3.en.ergolinear1581786
tnwmlc.en.ansi22301
Average single handedessie-3.en.ergolinear79893
tnwmlc.en.ansi11150.5
Same finger bigramsseelpy-1.en.ergolinear8.01428.12
mcgunnigle-peoples.en.ansi1757.11

Fraser Street analysis

"Fraser Street" (thanks Shai) is a specially-crafted text in which most of the words are typed with only the left hand, on the QWERTY layout.
It was designed to highlight how much better the Dvorak layout is at hand alternation.
We ignore spaces and punctuation.

Left lettersRight lettersNeeds both hands
zZgGdDnNvVwWhHtTsSkKxXcCpPlLiIoOuUfFqQeEaArRbBjJmMyY

Fraser Street was in West Everett. Westward of Fraser Street was the great vast sea. Awed, we gazed seawards, attracted by crested waves which raced and ebbed. Children were scattered on the beach edged and strewed with seaweed. They waded in water as the sea surged in and retreated. They bagged crabs as eagerly as beavers saw trees. Brave crews, seafarers in fact, steered sea craft far away. The site of Fraser Street was not overrated.

Few vegetated in Fraser Street. Nobody wasted time abed. "Acts test the breed," was ever the sacred adage. Varied crafts and trades were represented. There was a caterer, a barber, a weaver, a cabaret, and a garage. Attracted, we started to see several scenes. We were greeted as friends.

The barber catered to a varied trade, representing diverse careers and different creeds. Saturday drew the best crowd. All were seated, relaxed, aware of fewer cares, less fagged. There we saw a few starved tattered beggars who bragged of "bracers" served at cafes after a wee meal of beef stew and cabbage. A better fare was reserved for those reared on earth's greater awards.

Fraser Street summary

Left letters typed379
Right letters typed502
Needs both hands0
Total letters typed881
Switches478
Hand balance43.02 : 0.00 : 56.98

Typing lessons

Download some English words suitable for learning the layout.
Note if any files are empty it's because there are not enough words to create a lesson. This is most noticeable in the bad layouts.

Week 1Homekey words Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 2Easyblock words Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 3Homeblock words Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 4Common / tricky words Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 5Pangrams Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 6So you think you can type? Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 7Extra practice 1: Common words in text Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 8Extra practice 2: Lorem ipsum and friends Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5
Week 9Extra practice 3: Underused words Day 1 Day 2 Day 3 Day 4 Day 5